A Case For Thrifting

A Case For Thrifting

brown suede bit loafers
Cole Haan of yesteryear...

I don’t thrift often, but when I do the return on my investment of time and money is often relatively high.  Sometimes I will go out for a day and hit a bunch of thrift stores whereas other times I will simply stumble upon one and stop in.  I rarely will not go into a thrift store when I pass one, you never know what you’ll find and if you have never been there before it is a good idea to scope the place out for future visits (if possible).

To keep expectations reasonable I should say I don’t think I have ever thrifted something that didn’t require alterations, which is acceptable to my mind.  Obviously, the idea is to limit the need for alterations, but don’t go out expecting to avoid them altogether.  Even buying a jacket for $15 and putting in $60 of alterations gives me a jacket that cost $75, whereas as I am used to spending at least $400 for a jacket.

brown suede bit loafers
You know your shoes are thrifted when the price is on the sole…

So anyway, in short I have found there are four potential outcomes to my (and probably your) thrifting efforts that I think it is useful to keep in mind.  Each of which have a time and place and the latter three can help you better your wardrobe.

1. Buying something that I will never alter or wear.  I often bought items like this because I liked the fabric or style or I was being impulsive.  These items eventually get donated to my local stores (I refuse to donate to Goodwill as I don’t view it as a true charity).

2. Buying something that I will alter and wear that I didn’t necessarily need, but I wanted at the time.  Or something that I would never spend the money on to buy new.  I have a few aggressively patterned jackets that fall into this category.

3.  Buying something that I will alter and wear that will hold me over until I can buy something custom that I will be happier with.  As an example, I recently purchased a summer weight blue sports jacket that after alterations fits well but I am not happy with the lapels and gorge height of it.

4.  Buying something that will completely eliminate the need for a future purchase.  For example, last week I found a pair of brown suede bit loafers from Cole Haan (from a time when the brand made shoes of good quality).

brown suede bit loafers

A bit more back story is needed to fully asses the value of the 4th type of good.  I have been wanting a pair of brown suede or brown calf bit loafers for nearly two years but hadn’t gotten around the justifying the expense yet as they are many items I need more than them.  But my patience was rewarded.  Instead of spending between $325-550 (Alden of Gucci basically) I spent $15.  Years of wear are expected from these shoes and after cleaning them with some Saphir suede cleaner they should look noticeably better.  I figure I saved at least $300, not bad for a few minutes work and a few years waiting.  I wouldn’t recommend putting off more essential purchases like a blazer, first (or second) suit or first (or second) pair of dress shoes in hopes of finding suitable options in a thrift store.  So I think this strategy works better for second or third tier ‘necessities.’  But nonetheless, I recommend taking every chance you get to stop in a thrift store, you never know what you’ll find.


brown suede bit loafers


  1. I don’t thrift often either, because my tall thin build makes it hard to find sizes, even with extensive tailoring. But yesterday I dropped by a store near me on a lark and hit a nice little treasure trove — two bespoke suits made by a British tailor in Hong Kong (charcoal pinstripe flannel and lightweight nautical blue worsted wool, $10 each) and a vintage Daks double-breasted navy blazer with fantastic heavyweight brass buttons, originally purchased at a tailor’s in Bermuda ($6). Everything fits like it was made for me, which is VERY unusual (might need to have the trousers taken in an inch or so) — obviously someone was getting rid of parts of their wardrobe. Been a long time since I hit a score like that, but it makes all the other trips worthwhile.

  2. I spent a lot of time thrifting when I was first building a wardrobe and when I lost a lot of weight and had to replace that wardrobe. But I live in the middle of the midwest in a city without a good history of discerning dressers, so it is RARE to find anything worthwhile in a thrift store.

    I could buy truckloads of Kirkland plaid button downs. But no thanks.

  3. Not a ‘thrifting’ find – but related to a serendipitous (for me) great find with a lack of tailoring. I was working in a quality mens wear store… we had a regular customer that purchased four suits and had them altered (Boss and Zegna). He passed away before he could pick them up. His wife said to get rid of them…. they fit me perfectly.